The Flooding Box Was Blank. The Sinkhole Sign Wasn't.

A California home changes hands under dual agency. According to the state's later Accusation, the Transfer Disclosure Statement left the flooding question blank, and a sign on the street out front read 'SINK HOLE.' About two years after closing, the California Department of Real Estate filed that Accusation. A public discipline file from early 2025 is a reminder that blank boxes and neighborhood conditions both show up in the record.
What the filings say
This one isn't an appeals opinion; it's a California Department of Real Estate discipline matter, so everything below is what the Accusation and the Commissioner's Decision and Order say, not what a civil court decided about the property. According to Accusation H-7323 SAC, filed May 8, 2024, a broker represented both the seller and the buyer as a dual agent on a residential resale in Loomis, California (Placer County), that closed March 31, 2022.
The Accusation alleges that the Transfer Disclosure Statement provided to the buyer left several Section C questions blank, with neither Yes nor No checked, including flooding, drainage or grading problems; major damage from fire, earthquake, floods or landslides; zoning violations, nonconforming uses or setback requirements; and neighborhood noise problems or other nuisances. It also alleges that a sign labeled 'SINK HOLE' was placed on the street directly in front of the property before close, that the broker knew about the sign, that the buyer never saw it, and that the Agent Visual Inspection Disclosure did not disclose the sinkhole issue affecting the street.
The same Accusation alleges that when the broker had earlier represented the buyer who purchased that property in August 2021, the sellers' TDS on that prior sale checked Yes to flooding, drainage or grading problems. The broker later listed that same property for the later dual-agency sale.
By Stipulation and Agreement adopted as the Commissioner's Decision and Order (effective noon on February 6, 2025), the broker's real estate broker license was revoked, with a right to a restricted salesperson license. The corporate broker license of the brokerage was voluntarily surrendered, also effective February 6, 2025. There was no hearing. To settle the case, the broker chose not to contest the Accusation's factual allegations, and the order rests on those allegations. This post describes the filings; it doesn't decide what happened at the property.
Why this one is worth a second look
Blank Yes/No boxes on a Transfer Disclosure Statement leave the file without a clear answer on the very conditions California's statutory form asks about. In this case, one broker was on both sides of the deal, and the Accusation alleges the broker and brokerage breached fiduciary duties to the buyer by failing to ensure the flooding and sinkhole issue was disclosed before close of escrow.
In this file, the Accusation points to the Agent Visual Inspection Disclosure as the form where the sinkhole issue on the street went unmentioned. When the form and the street don't match, the mismatch itself becomes part of the story later.
A quick check before your client removes contingencies
Before contingencies come off, ask: is every Yes/No item on the TDS answered, with no blanks in Section C? If this is a dual agency, did the same questions get the same attention as they would with separate agents? Does the Agent Visual Inspection Disclosure mention neighborhood or street conditions that a walk-up would show? If the file has an earlier TDS or prior sale package, does it answer a question the current forms leave blank?
These aren't legal questions for House Owl to answer. They're plain-English file questions a careful second read can raise early, so the right professional can take them from there.
What's at stake
Here, a dual-agency resale closed in March 2022, an Accusation followed in May 2024, and by February 2025 the broker license was revoked (with a restricted salesperson path) and the corporate license was surrendered. Making sure the seller answers every box, and that the agent's own forms match what's visible at the property, is a much smaller step.
How House Owl helps
We understand how overwhelming the paperwork is. You're the one guiding your client through it. House Owl is a second set of eyes on your disclosures and transaction documents, so questions get caught and referred to the right professional before close.
A simple plan for your next escrow
1. Book a free 30-minute Learn More call. (https://calendly.com/jason-myhouseowl/learn-more-1)
2. We review your disclosures and transaction documents for inconsistencies and red flags.
3. We walk your client through what we found on a recorded video call, and you're invited to join, so they can close with more confidence.
Why House Owl
An independent second read of your disclosures and transaction documents, with the walkthrough saved as a video recording. We can send a quick recap after the review, and if something needs your attention, we reach out to you directly.
Jason Piske has worked in California real estate since 2016 and offers disclosure-risk training to brokerages. You can see how it works on our Services page (/services-new) and get quick answers in our FAQ (/faq). Payment terms are in our Terms (https://www.myhouseowl.com/terms-and-conditions).
Close with more confidence
Clients who understand their documents before they sign. That's the outcome worth working toward on every file.
A second set of eyes on your disclosures.
For more information, book a free 30-minute Learn More call. (https://calendly.com/jason-myhouseowl/learn-more-1)
Sources
DRE Accusation, H-7323 SAC (filed May 8, 2024): https://www2.dre.ca.gov/hearingfiles/H07323SAC_240508_P.pdf ; Decision and Order / Stipulation (effective Feb. 6, 2025): https://www2.dre.ca.gov/hearingfiles/H07323SAC_250206_P.pdf
General information, not legal advice. House Owl is an independent document review service, not a law firm, real estate brokerage or home inspector. Owner Jason Piske is a California real estate licensee (DRE 02004501), but in a House Owl review he doesn't act as anyone's agent or represent any party. Laws differ by state; talk to a qualified attorney in your state about a specific situation.



Comments